Lip Liner

I have tried these in Zen, Perfection, Charisma, and Island Spice. To me it seems that Zen is a bit paler than shown in the "swatch" picture on the website, but the description (warm pink) is...

I have this in Zen, which is a rosey tan shade. The lip liner formula is creamy, easy to apply and lasts as long as any other lip liner I have used. Nice ingredients and gluten free.