Volumizing Mascara

I have it in Plum, I hate the formula! It doesn't volumize, it's clumpy and crumbles throughout the day and the little crumbles fall into my eyes! I like the color, but that is all. My favorite...

I am on my third tube of this - it lengthens and volumizes better than any of the HE ones I have tried. I buy black, but this does come in brown. I haven't tried the new formula yet but I have...