Intensity

I just got this and don't know what to think. It looks beautiful in the pot, but muddy on my eyelid. The shimmer disappears on application. I don't think it's worth $20, so I'm returning...

A matte light-medium shade of gray. Buildable coverage, goes on smoothly, blends well, stays put, no creasing. Looks great with Margaux and Twilight Grey. However, the color isn't exactly a...