Color Options Lip gloss

I bought "Cherry" on ebay, and I'm glad I didn't spend a lot of money on it. Mainly, I just don't like the thick, sticky texture. The color is actually pretty true -- which surprised me b/c I was...

I bought Buff. The color is a very pretty nude pink but the gloss is very thick and sticky. Looks nice, feels "icky". Although it's OK I won't buy another one.