Almay intense i-color defining liner

I bought this in Onyx. Onyx is a true black, with flecks of shimmer. I use it a lot to line my bottom lash line, and I love it. I have found, as I aged, that I needed more definition in my...

I just can't seem to find a use for the smudging tool on these things. If you rub the liner it just moves it around until it's gone. I'm not a big fan of having to sharpen eye liner. But anyway......

I got this liner in the color charcoal, and let me tell you I LOVE this stuff. Not only does it stay on all day but comes off easy at night, it has subtle sparkle in it. This color is a very...