Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner Matte Black

Eh. This eyeliner is just...okay. I'm a dancer and I needed some black eyeliner for my shows. I bought this because I was still a beginner with eyeliner, and retractable pens worked the best for...

This eyeliner seems to be the replacement for their regular black which was great. However, the new matte black is a different shade of black, cooler greyish black and not suited for warmer tones....