What's the blackest, softest, densest, smudgeable eye pencil?


message by sugar800
more messages

expand whole threadWhat's the blackest, softest, densest, smudgeable eye pencil?sugar8005/15/2013 10:36AM

MAC Feline no doubt!MUrascal5/15/2013 1:06PM

Urban Decays 24/7 Eyeliner Pencil in Perversion...glamourbytch5/15/2013 12:07PM

I woulda said BF Bad Gal--not black enough?Beth5/15/2013 11:06AM

mac feline,rimmel scandal eyes,avons supershock.macwannab5/15/2013 11:03AM

Urban Decay PerversionKica5/15/2013 11:03AM

2nddreamsicle235/15/2013 11:48AM

Mac smoldertuts3115/15/2013 10:43AM

Yep, def smolderpronks5/15/2013 10:53AM

That's what I have my eye onsugar8005/15/2013 10:51AM

this blooiejagwa5/15/2013 10:45AM

rimmel kohl. I have repurchased this at least 5xmartiantraveler5/15/2013 10:40AM

Interesting - & is this also against you trying high end brands? & what about Scandaleyes rec below?sugar8005/15/2013 10:51AM

yes, better than the HE brands I've tried. Haven't tried scandaleyes. I use the kohl on my+martiantraveler5/15/2013 11:00AM

Hmm I want smudgey deep goodness but also want to apply it underneath eyes!sugar8005/15/2013 11:12AM

But at Rimmel prices can't hurt to get it & trysugar8005/15/2013 11:12AM

Rimmel Scandaleyes in black. lomelindi5/15/2013 10:40AM

I big time 2nd this! I love this pencil but all of my local stores are always sold out! So I'm ++vwzen815/15/2013 11:14AM

Have you also tried the Rimmel Kohl one?sugar8005/15/2013 10:51AM

Nope :) I got Scandaleyes 'cause it's supposedly waterproof and rubproof lollomelindi5/15/2013 10:54AM

Is it easily smudgey & pigmentedsugar8005/15/2013 11:13AM

It smudges easily in the first 10 seconds or so, so get all of your smudging done then! Once it +lomelindi5/15/2013 11:50AM

Stila kajalahousefellonmysister5/15/2013 10:38AM

2ndkeepitreal5/15/2013 10:55AM